Surely most people who have come to this country contribute far more to the economy over the course of their lives than tourists who come here for a few weeks.

Whilst I agree that everybody in this country should be encouraged to learn English, we should not impose such draconian rules in health care. A far better saving could be made by stopping all government publications and websites needing to be made available in Welsh - a language that almost nobody speaks, and those who do all speak English as well.

However, if I were being treated in a Welsh hospital I would hope that they would explain to me what was happening in English rather than Welsh, even if that meant getting a translator.

Anyway, good to have a pointless debate on a Friday.