Merely to say that there's no evidence to suggest a service is going to stay is hardly a convincing argument. The loop line is there. In May, it's being expanded with extra early morning services. To be able to say that we are going to lose this services "for sure", you have to provide some evidence.

You claim that axing this service is "current thinking". Current thinking by whom exactly and what documentary or other evidence is there of these discussions?

I'm genuinely open to persuasion. If the rail authorities are already discussing this cut we need to know about this.

So please supply evidence.