My issue with the applicant? Their history in the building industry. Especially with regards to #6.
The damage they have done to my house and existance there is already bad enough, but the thought that they will again be allowed to chip away at the foundations again is actually scary!
To add to it, lets just say there is a serious health issue in this property, and any upset and disruption from the site next door will make the situation worse, in my opinion anyway.
I would be interested to see how many people will both be invited and actually take up the invite to consult on this application. Having a voice, and choosing to use it are 2 totally different things.
I agree totally with your comments on what should be done as far as the replacement property.